Troubleshooting Dynamic Import Failures and Misbundled Dependencies in Rollup

Details: Category: Build & Bundling; By Mindful Chase; 22.Mar; Hits: 21

Rollup is a modern JavaScript module bundler known for its efficient tree-shaking, ES module support, and optimal bundle outputs. It's often favored in libraries and frameworks that prioritize size and modularity. However, as projects scale and adopt advanced configurations—like multiple entry points, dynamic imports, and complex plugin chains—teams often encounter intricate build issues. One such challenge arises from unresolved external dependencies, broken imports during dynamic module loading, and build output inconsistencies that affect deployment or downstream consumers. This article dives deep into diagnosing and resolving such complex issues with Rollup in large-scale or enterprise-grade JavaScript ecosystems.

Mindful Chase

Writing Code, Writing Stories

tbd

Experience

tbd

More to Explore

Understanding the Problem

Dynamic Imports and External Dependencies Failing at Runtime

In sophisticated applications, especially libraries published as packages, Rollup may output builds that reference dynamic imports or external packages incorrectly. This manifests in errors like "Cannot find module" or blank screen issues in applications consuming these builds.

Error: Uncaught (in promise) TypeError: Failed to fetch dynamically imported module
at runtimeModuleLoader (dist/index.js:99)

These problems often stem from incorrect configuration of the external, output.dynamicImportFunction, or plugin settings within Rollup's config file.

Architectural Context

How Rollup Works with Modern Module Systems

Rollup builds JavaScript applications using a graph of ES modules, statically analyzing dependencies to remove unused code (tree-shaking) and bundle outputs in formats like ESM, CJS, UMD, or SystemJS. Rollup expects to resolve all modules at build time unless marked as external.

Challenges in Enterprise Setups

Multi-package monorepos (e.g., with Lerna or Nx) complicate dependency resolution across packages.
Dynamic imports in libraries must be handled differently than in apps, as consumers may need to resolve them.
Plugins like node-resolve, commonjs, or babel may misbehave depending on resolution order.

Diagnosing the Issue

1. Audit Rollup Config File

Check if external dependencies are correctly marked. Any package listed in dependencies (not devDependencies) should usually be marked as external in library builds.

external: ["react", "react-dom", "lodash"]

Failure to do this can lead to React or other packages being bundled, causing version mismatches.

2. Review Dynamic Import Behavior

Rollup supports dynamic import(), but requires proper configuration when output format is not ESM. Ensure you're setting output.inlineDynamicImports or output.dynamicImportFunction correctly.

output: {
  format: "esm",
  dir: "dist",
  preserveModules: true,
  entryFileNames: "[name].js"
}

3. Inspect Plugin Order

Plugin execution order matters. Misordered plugins (e.g., placing babel before commonjs) can prevent proper transformation of dependencies.

plugins: [
  resolve(),
  commonjs(),
  babel({ babelHelpers: "bundled" })
]

4. Validate File Paths and Imports

Incorrect import paths (especially in dynamic imports) may go unnoticed during build but fail at runtime.

// Avoid relative dynamic imports
import(`./pages/${page}.js`) // May fail if not preserved correctly

5. Use Rollup's --watch and Verbose Logging

When debugging build issues, run with rollup -c --watch --verbose to observe module resolution and warnings in real time.

Common Pitfalls and Root Causes

1. Incorrect External Dependency Handling

If a library inadvertently includes external packages, it bloats the bundle and may break consuming apps with duplicate React or Vue versions.

2. Dynamic Imports in CommonJS Builds

Rollup does not fully support dynamic imports in CommonJS output. These must be either inlined or transformed using plugins like rollup-plugin-dynamic-import-vars.

3. Missing PreserveModules for Shared Libraries

Libraries using shared modules across builds should use preserveModules to maintain file structure. This is critical for tree-shaking in consumers.

4. Unused Plugin Options or Deprecated Plugins

Old or unmaintained plugins (like legacy Babel plugins) may silently fail or be incompatible with recent Node or Rollup versions.

5. Mismatched Output Formats

Generating a bundle as iife or cjs but consuming it in an ESM context without interop flags can lead to "unexpected token export" errors.

Step-by-Step Fix

Step 1: Separate App and Library Builds

If you're building both, use different configs. For libraries, avoid bundling externals. For apps, bundle all required modules.

Step 2: Review and Refactor Rollup Config

Ensure clear separation of input, output, and plugin responsibilities. Avoid dynamic constructs unless strictly needed.

export default {
  input: "src/index.ts",
  output: [
    { format: "esm", dir: "dist/esm" },
    { format: "cjs", dir: "dist/cjs" }
  ],
  external: ["react"],
  plugins: [
    resolve(),
    commonjs(),
    typescript()
  ]
}

Step 3: Convert Dynamic Imports to Static If Possible

Many dynamic imports can be converted to static ones with named entry points for safer bundling.

Step 4: Use PreserveModules for Package Outputs

Maintain individual file outputs with preserveModules to allow consumers to tree-shake properly.

Step 5: Test with Downstream Consumers

Always test the built output in a separate repo or sample app to ensure it works under common environments (Webpack, Vite, Node).

Best Practices for Rollup in Enterprise Projects

Modularize Config Files

Split large Rollup configs by platform (web, node, esm, cjs) for maintainability. Use shared constants for paths and dependency lists.

Audit External vs. Bundled Dependencies

Automate checks to ensure only intended packages are bundled. Use Rollup's onwarn to detect unresolved modules.

Use Package Exports in package.json

Modern consumers rely on proper exports maps. Ensure your library specifies correct paths for each output format.

"exports": {
  ".": {
    "import": "./dist/esm/index.js",
    "require": "./dist/cjs/index.js"
  }
}

Leverage TypeScript for Type Safety

If using TS, ensure tsconfig.json aligns with Rollup output expectations. Generate declaration files separately if needed.

Pin Plugin Versions and Monitor Updates

Rollup plugins evolve rapidly. Pin versions and validate regularly to prevent regressions caused by breaking changes.

Conclusion

Rollup is a highly efficient bundler, but its flexibility means it can be misconfigured in complex projects. The intersection of plugin order, module formats, dynamic imports, and external declarations introduces nuanced problems that don't surface until runtime. Understanding how Rollup builds and resolves modules is essential when creating libraries or micro frontends. With careful configuration, modular outputs, and consistent testing in downstream consumers, teams can produce robust, production-ready bundles that scale reliably across environments.

FAQs

1. Why does Rollup bundle external dependencies despite marking them as external?

This can happen if the plugin order is incorrect or a plugin like CommonJS forcibly resolves the dependency. Ensure external is respected before plugins are applied.

2. Can I use dynamic imports in Rollup for libraries?

Yes, but only in ESM format with consumers that support dynamic imports. For CommonJS, these must be transformed or avoided.

3. What does preserveModules do in Rollup?

It maintains the original file structure and allows consumers to import only what they need, improving tree-shaking and modular usage.

4. How do I fix "unexpected token export" in consuming apps?

This typically happens when ESM output is consumed in CJS environments. Ensure dual output formats or proper package.json exports are provided.

5. How can I verify what's actually included in the Rollup bundle?

Use the rollup-plugin-visualizer to inspect your final bundle. It provides a treemap of all modules and their sizes.

Contact Us